HOLY SHIT, I FOUND A CASTLE!
This was after a map to the forge and a map to a wishing well mysteriously appeared from somewhere. I answered the frog’s questions again, and it gave me more chocolate, which allowed me to completely coat my sword in chocolate, making it a Chocolate Sword. Which in the world of Candy Box is stronger than a Diamond Sword. Duh. Having a Chocolate Sword means I could forge it into a health draining Sword of Life, which the sorceress could then enchant. And then the wishing well gave me 63 assorted potions and scrolls.
One of which is a Superman Potion, which gives me a cape and makes me look like Superman for the duration of a quest.
Man, this game is awesome. And weird. And awesome.